Political leadership versus diplomacy

  • 6th March 2019
Political leadership versus diplomacy

Jeffrey Robertson
, lowyinstitute.org
[JB note: From the article, a notable quotation: “Any junior diplomat who has waited hours at the airport for a politician’s arrival knows there is a big difference between political leadership and diplomacy.”]
Image result for Political leadership versus diplomacyuncaptioned image from article
Following the Trump-Kim summits and a gush of commentary on “presidential diplomacy”, “face-to-face diplomacy”, “summit diplomacy”, and even “Trumpian diplomacy”, we’ve somehow come to accept politicians as diplomats. It may be time to recall the difference – before it’s too late.In chess, leadership pieces are played at the right time. The King is vulnerable and is protected, the Queen is powerful and used strategically. Why send the leaders out at the earliest stages?While it may be splitting hairs, leadership summits are not “diplomacy”. If we consider diplomacy to be the mediation of estranged entities by official representatives, then leadership summits aren’t diplomacy. Even the simplest definition, diplomacy is what diplomats do, then leadership summits aren’t diplomacy. There’s certainly lots of diplomacy before, around, and after summits – negotiation, protocol, drafting, public diplomacy [JB emphasis], reporting – but what the leaders themselves actually do is not diplomacy – it’s political leadership.History is a powerful teacher. Political leadership and diplomacy evolved over thousands of years into distinct fields. While a leader can display diplomacy, and a diplomat can display leadership – they are very different roles. There are good reasons for this separation.First, political leaders are reliant on domestic electoral or other power bases. This means they focus on domestic events, and domestic stakeholders and supporters influence their decision making. Social media means what is external is also domestic – and vice versa. It’s hard to imagine former White House lawyer Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony not influencing Trump’s performance. In contrast, diplomats are public servants. Their performance depends solely on standards of integrity and professionalism.Second, in strategic terms, political leadership is an instrument to be brought out at the right time – not on opening. In chess, leadership pieces are played at the right time. The King is vulnerable and is protected, the Queen is powerful and used strategically. Why send the leaders out at the earliest stages? Let the Pawns (Foreign Service Officers) do the early work, the Knights, Bishops and Rooks (Under-Secretaries, Deputy Secretaries, and Special Representatives) do the set-up, and the King or Queen (Secretary of State or President) take the glory.Third, having leaders play a larger role at opening, essentially when working level negotiations are still underway, makes subsequent delegation impossible. The delegate is discounted and is seen as an impediment to the decision maker. The role of US Special Representative for North Korea, Stephen Biegun, was already difficult with Trump’s undermining Twitter platitudes. It becomes more difficult with every summit. Excluding him from the “social dinner” at the Metropole didn’t help either.

Kim Jong-un and Donald Trump in a “social dinner” at the Metropole hotel in Hanoi (Photo: White House/Flickr)

Finally, political leaders are not trained in diplomacy. Politicians profit from rhetoric. They tend towards the emotional, dramatic, sentimental, moral, or exhibitive aspects of interaction. They want “quick fixes” and to “win” or “walk away”. Diplomats profit from reliability, accuracy, patience, modesty and tact. They seek practical, common sense, outcomes – arriving at a position which best accommodates their needs that are also acceptable to the other side.Most importantly, the idea that political leaders can profit from “friendship”, “trust” or any other form of intuitive supposition made at a summit is laughable. Diplomatic trust cannot be built through leadership summits.Believing political leaders can gain a solid understanding of a partner’s intentions through face-to-face meetings is according them undeserved capabilities that exist only in the domain of psychologists, intelligence agents, and used car dealers. Imagining that three or four meetings within the term of a presidency can achieve what diplomats establish over an entire career belies the concept of diplomatic trust.Diplomats know that trust and intention cannot be discerned by handshakes, voice tone, facial expressions, eye contact, twitches, or body posture. Culture affects negotiation. Culture can make eye contact honest or aggressive, and a smile welcoming or weird. Diplomats overcome such differences through tacit knowledge, experience and universal modes of interaction or protocol. For a diplomat, trust itself is based on the idea that a partner can hold their word and secure the support to fulfil agreements. This trust can only be built up over time and through repeated interaction.British diplomat Harold Nicolson argued there is a stock market of diplomatic reputation that’s built up over repeated interaction. As classes of diplomats from partner countries progress through the ranks they come to an estimation of each other’s character. When they face each other in major negotiations at the senior levels of their career, they already know who is reliable and who is not, who to trust, and who to distrust. Diplomacy evolved as a permanent institution in every capital city across the globe because it facilitated the building of diplomatic trust, which in turn supplemented the lack of political trust.Political leadership and diplomacy are different. Remembering this points to the need to fill the ranks of the foreign ministries, give diplomats the trust, confidence and resources they deserve, and allow them to do their jobs. Any junior diplomat who has waited hours at the airport for a politician’s arrival knows there is a big difference between political leadership and diplomacy. It’s time senior political leaders recognise this as well.
Original Article

Please follow and like us:

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages


  • Kako je Fejsbuk u Srbiji počeo borbu protiv lažnih vesti 7th August 2020
    Dok jedni smatraju da su društvene mreže jedina slobodna platforma koja podržava slobodu izražavanja, drugi kažu da one predstavljaju oružje za prljavu borbu lažima sa neistomišljenicima. Nedavno je kompanija Fejsbuk u Srbiji objavila rat lažnim vestima, uz pomoć AFP-a i Istinomera. Novinarke Frans presa Katarina Subašić i Marion Dotri tokom jula otkrile su 13 lažnih […]
  • COVID-19 vaccine developed in Austria – produced in Scotland 5th August 2020
    Skip to content Leigh Turner Ambassador to Austria and UK Permanent Representative to the United Nations and other International Organisations in Vienna Part of UK in Austria 5th August 2020 Vienna, Austria COVID-19 vaccine developed in Austria – produced in Scotland “When we started to develop our vaccine candidate we needed to push; now there […]

RSS Diplo Portal Belgrade

  • Stipendije Marija Kiri – Korak ka naučnim uspesima 10th August 2020
    Evropska komisija omogućava istraživačima iz celog sveta da 2020. iskoriste na najbolji način, da steknu naučnu i finansijsku nezavisnost da naprave veliki korak za sebe i doprinesu povećanju naučno istraživačkog fonda znanja. U okviru Programa Marie Skłodovska-Curie (MSCA) objavljena su dva poziva za podršku istraživačima u svim fazama karijere, bez obzira na starosnu dob i […]
  • Дань памяти: глава Россотрудничества Евгений Примаков возложил цветы к монументам воинской славы в Орле 10th August 2020
    В 77-летнюю годовщину освобождения Орла от немецко-фашистских захватчиков руководитель Россотрудничества Евгений Примаков и руководство областных и муниципальных властей возложили цветы к монументам воинской славы в Сквере Танкистов. Участники мемориальной церемонии почтили память советских солдат, отдавших жизнь за Отечество в годы Великой Отечественной войны. В 1943 году в честь освобожденных Орла и Белгорода в Москве был […]

Catalog of Destroyed and Desecrated Churches in Kosovo ( VIDEO )

How Belgrade based diplomats use Digital Diplomacy and Internet 2016

Diplo Portal Belgrade

Please follow and like us:
Scroll Up

Enjoy BIDD? Please spread the word :)