Public-Diplomacy Blast from the Past — on the sad occasion of the tragic death of an American missionary

  • 1st December 2018
  • 242 Views
Public-Diplomacy Blast from the Past — on the sad occasion of the tragic death of an American missionary

THE BLOG 05/11/2010 05:12 am ET Updated May 25, 2011Public Diplomacy: The World Should Be Teaching Us, Mr. KristofheadshotBy John Brown, Huffington Post (2011); reposted, as it may be indirectly pertinent to well meaning and idealistic Peace Corps volunteers, re the tragic death of the missionary — John Allen Chau — killed on a remote Indian Ocean island; see (1)
Well-meaning Nicholas D. Kristof in the New York Times:

“Peace Corps and Teach for America represent the best ethic of public service. But at a time when those programs can’t meet the demand from young people seeking to give back, we need a new initiative: Teach for the World.In my mind, Teach for the World would be a one-year program placing young Americans in schools in developing countries. The Americans might teach English or computer skills, or coach basketball or debate teams. …This would be a government-financed effort to supplement an American public diplomacy outreach that has been eviscerated over the last few decades.”

Mr. Kristof, who wants young Americans to teach English the world over, seems unaware that all too many of us here in the homeland (which is how we now identify our cry-the-beloved country in these sad post-9/11 times) are incapable of writing a coherent English sentence free of grammatical and spelling errors. And how many of us called-to-duty language missionaries currently living in said homeland, if volunteering to coach “debate teams” overseas, could actually be capable of crafting a logical argument, given our 24/7 we-can’t-stop-loving-it culture of instant mindless gratification a la Tee-Vee & Twitter & uptalk?“I mean, like you know, whatever” — such is, increasingly, our American contribution to serious world-wide discourse.Well, OK, post-modern language/argument, without oh-so-boring grammar or logic, is maybe what we in the New World have to offer to our globalized planet. No problem. (Actually, I’m all for this Americanization, until I read, as I often do, a paper “written” by a computer-savvy US undergraduate that makes absolutely no, I mean absolutely no, sense, not even, dare I say, from a “post-modernist” perspective).In my Foreign Service career, I found many distinguished foreigners who spoke English better than I did (and pray tell, Mr. Kristof, what is a “developing country”? Detroit, Michigan?). These distinguished foreigners had actually read, very carefully, English-language classics and knew the fundamentals of classical rhetoric, hence their ability to engage in serious debate. I thought they should be teaching me.As for the Peace Corps, its main drawbacks are twofold.(A) Giving jobs to too many well-meaning but desperately-seeking-to-be-employed, résumé-driven, undereducated provincial American BA’s with, all too often, little or no knowledge of foreign languages/cultures or substantial skills, personal or intellectual, even in teaching (or speaking) their own native language.There are, of course, notable exceptions, including “senior citizens” in the program; but much of the Peace Corps is, I would suggest, an updated, “democratic” version of a vast system of outdoor relief for the upper classes.In all fairness, these well-meaning, often naive, Peace Corps volunteers (I had the privilege of meeting many of them in my Foreign Service career), may be eager to learn about the outside world. But if they are parachuted to teach/“set an example” in other countries, they should know far more about them (and their own country and language) than Peace Corps “training” provides (and by the time they know something about where they are, they are shipped out).(B) As suggested by the above remarks, most sadly and importantly, the Peace Corps is not a bilateral program. In essence, “we” (the U.S.) are telling “them” (the “foreigners”) what to do (in a gentle way) — a twentieth-century Cold War one-way-communications propaganda model, granted on a perhaps laudable human level.But today (I won’t say at a time of US “decline”) we “altruistic” American taxpayers could certainly use highly-skilled volunteers from other countries, including math teachers from “developing countries,” for our poorly performing public secondary schools, in exchange for our own volunteers, who would be far more skilled than many in our well-meaning Peace Corps currently are. In this way we would be honestly serving our own interests, while at the same time asking for the world’s cooperation, when and where we need it.The world should teaching us, Mr. Kristof, in more ways than one. Not just the U.S. teaching the world. Time for a real deal.Original Article

Please follow and like us:

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages

RSS BIDD

  • Israeli Corona Greeting Goes Viral in Arab World 27th March 2020
    “May Allah keep you, our cousins.” Warm messages such as that have been flooding into the Arabic-language social media accounts of the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. They come in response to a post featuring a selfie of three Ministry employees and a message of support and hope to the Arab world. After being posted […]
  • “We can be heroes. Just for one day.” 25th March 2020
    Skip to content Matt Field British Ambassador to Bosnia and Herzegovina 25th March 2020 Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina “We can be heroes. Just for one day.” I sit to write this blog at a table in my home. Like many people across Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH), and in fact the world, I am currently working […]

RSS Diplo Portal Belgrade

  • Albania Sends 30 Doctors to Help Italy Fight Coronavirus 28th March 2020
    Original Article The post Albania Sends 30 Doctors to Help Italy Fight Coronavirus appeared first on Diplomatic portal.
  • Влада: Продужена самоизолација, викендом полицијски час од 15 часова 28th March 2020
    БЕОГРАД, 28. марта (Тањуг) – Влада Србије данас је донела одлуку да се све мере самоизолације продуже са 14 на 28 дана, а викендом забрана кретања уведе од 15 часова. То су најновије мере које је влада донела на данашњој седници за спречавање ширења вируса COVID-19, саопштила је владина Канцеларија за сарадњу са медијима. Свим […]

Catalog of Destroyed and Desecrated Churches in Kosovo ( VIDEO )

How Belgrade based diplomats use Digital Diplomacy and Internet 2016

Diplo Portal Belgrade

Please follow and like us:
Scroll Up
error

Enjoy BIDD? Please spread the word :)